MMXXVI VOL21 No.941

First Tokyo raid was 84 years ago in 1942

COLUMN II 1$

col2.com

Titanic millionaire’s boat

After the Titanic collided with an iceberg, evacuation of the passengers in lifeboats began. Lifeboat No. 1, with a capacity for 40 people, was launched with only 5 first‑class passengers on board. After accusations that sailors had been bribed not to return to rescue survivors from the water when the liner went down, it became known as the millionaires’ boat
ExMachina - 1591836 views -
49 votoes 1 Star
Spanish version
Titanic millionaire’s boat

When the Titanic’s evacuation began at 12:40am on April 15, lifeboat No. 1 was launched with only 5 first class passengers on board, despite having capacity for 40 people.

After accusations that sailors had been bribed not to return to rescue survivors from the water when the liner finally went down, it was dubbed the “millionaires’ boat”. Here’s what really happened.

The Titanic collided with an iceberg on Sunday, April 14, at 11:40pm, after the 1st class passengers had attended a copious and extravagant 10‑course dinner with alcohol in abundance.

The captain orchestrated a scenario of apparent tranquility

After the collision, Captain Edward Smith orchestrated a scenario of apparent calm to avoid panic. He knew that the ship only had 20 lifeboats, with a capacity for 1100 people compared to the 2300 passengers including the crew.

While Smith was assessing damage with the ship’s architect, Thomas Andrews, passengers had been called to the deck with life jackets on “just in case”. Officially nothing serious had yet happened.

Titanic millionaire's boat
Titanic’s officers. Captain Smith is seated second from right, with 1st Officer Murdoch to his left. Standing, left to right; Purser Hugh McElroy, 2nd Officer Charles Lightoller, 3rd Officer Herbert Pitman, 4th Officer Joseph Boxhall, 5th Officer Harold Lowe. Seated, left to right; 6th Officer James Paul Moody, Chief Officer Henry Tingle Wilde, Captain Edward Smith, 1st Officer William Murdoch.

At 00:15 the first class lounge was opened and the orchestra began to play ragtime. Orders were given to keep two boilers running to maintain the electrical supply at all costs so that the ship’s lights would remain on.

After inspecting the damage caused by the iceberg, Thomas Andrews accurately predicted that the Titanic would sink within 2 hours because she was not designed to survive flooding in 6 breached watertight compartments.

At 00:20, the captain ordered the lifeboats to be lowered with the call “women and children first”. In other words, the men were deprived of the right to board a lifeboat because there was not even room for all the women and children.

Lifeboat No. 1

No. 1 was not a standard lifeboat. It was a small wooden emergency cutter, to be used by the crew in situations requiring quick action, such as a passenger falling overboard.

For this reason, this lifeboat was hung from the davits over the gunwale so that it could be quickly lowered.

Its capacity was lower than that of the other lifeboats, with room for 40 individuals as opposed to the 60 people that fit in the others.

Titanic millionaire's boat
Lifeboat No. 1, hanging from the davits over the gunwale so that it could be lowered quickly. On the upper deck, Captain Smith poking his head out.

Each lifeboat carried several crew members in charge of rowing. The most senior sailor was put in command. The other occupants were supposed to be women and children, whether they were passengers or employees of the vessel.

In the article on how to survive the sinking of the Titanic we pointed out that there were exceptions in which male passengers were allowed access to the lifeboats. One of the keys to surviving the sinking as a man was to be present in front of the lifeboat.

This was the case with lifeboat 1. Right beside it were several first-class travelers. Millionaire Sir Cosmo Duff Gordon, his wife Lucy “Lady” Duff Gordon, his secretary, Laura Mabel Francatelli, Abraham Lincoln Salomon, owner of a large stationery store in New York, and Charles Emil Henry, a Newark leather manufacturer whose wife had been embarked 22 minutes earlier on lifeboat No. 5.

The millionaires’ boat

No. 1 was the fourth lifeboat to be launched, at about 01:05. First Mate William McMaster Murdoch allowed the 3 first-class men who were present and the 2 women to board, manning the lifeboat with 7 male crewmen. Murdoch had already allowed several married couples and single men to board the 3 previous boats.

In the case of the Duff-Gordons, the wife had refused to board the first 3 lifeboats that were launched if her husband was not allowed access. When lifeboat No. 1 was to be occupied, there were no other women or children present, so Murdoch granted the husband permission.

With only 12 people on board, even though there was room for 40, Murdoch ordered the lifeboat to be lowered. It did not hit the water until 01:15 because they ran into several obstacles along the Titanic’s hull.

Titanic millionaire's boat
The passengers on the millionaires’ boat. On the left, Lady Lucy Duff-Gordon. Above right, her husband Cosmo Duff-Gordon. Below left, Charles Emil Henry. Bottom right, Abraham Lincoln Salomon. We should add Lady Duff-Gordon’s secretary, Laura Mabel Francatelli of whom there are no clear photos.

Why was lifeboat No. 1 lowered with only 12 people on board? First of all, it was Officer Murdoch’s decision. The most immediate reason is the seemingly calm scenario that Captain Smith had orchestrated. “Nothing is happening, we are lowering the boats as a simple precaution”.

Since the passengers were unaware of the real danger they were in, they were reluctant to board the first lifeboats that were launched because they were afraid. The boats were hanging from the davits on the Titanic’s upper deck, still very high in the first minutes of the tragedy.

On the first lifeboat lowered, No. 7 at 00:40, with a capacity for 65 occupants, only 28 people boarded.

The second lifeboat lowered, No. 5 at 00:43, with the same capacity, was occupied by only 36 people. The wealthiest passenger on board, John Jacob Astor, who was present, did not want to board, saying that “they were safer on board the ship than in that small boat”. He drowned later.

On the third lifeboat lowered, No. 3 at 01:00, only 38 people embarked. When several sailors saw No. 1 going down almost empty, they commented among themselves that if they were going to launch the boats, they should load them with people.

Lifeboat No. 1 did not return to rescue passengers

Once in the water, lifeboat No. 1, like the other boats, moved away from the Titanic to avoid being pulled down by the suction as the liner sank, which finally went down at 02:20.

In the distance, from lifeboat No. 1, the screams of the passengers left floating in the freezing water at -2ºC (35.6F) could be heard crying for help. They did not return. In less than an hour all but four in the drink were going to die of hypothermia.

Titanic millionaire's boat
Image taken from the RMS Carpathia of one of the Titanic’s boats with survivors. The photograph was archived without annotations. It is quite possible that it is lifeboat No. 1, the millionaire’s boat, because of its small size and because it is almost empty. The Titanic’s lifeboats were somewhat larger and had masts. The collapsible boats had waterproof canvas gunwales.

The harsh reality is that only one lifeboat went back to pick up survivors, lifeboat No. 14 under the command of Officer Lowe. The others refused for fear that people would capsize the boats as the victims desperately tried to climb aboard.

During the official inquiry into the sinking, the sailor in charge of lifeboat No. 1, Charles Hendrickson, stated that he proposed to return to rescue survivors but that the ladies aboard refused for fear of being sunk.

Lifeboat No. 1 and its occupants were rescued by the RMS Carpathia at 04:10. It was the second Titanic lifeboat to reach the ship that rescued the survivors.

The £5 bribe

At the official inquiry, Cosmo Duff-Gordon was questioned for offering £5 to each sailor if they did not return and kept rowing. The couple, the only passengers questioned in the proceedings, denied the allegations.

What had happened was that shortly after the Titanic sank, Lady Duff-Gordon said to her secretary “there goes your beautiful evening dress”. One of the sailors was annoyed by the comment and told her not to complain, that at least they had saved their lives, adding that the seamen had lost everything. They lost all their possessions – everything they owned was on the ship – and were without pay from the moment it sank. It was then that Cosmo Duff-Gordon offered them £5.

Titanic millionaire's boat
The sinking of the Titanic was front page news worldwide for months on end. When the newspapers got wind of the bribery allegation and the £5, they crucified Cosmo Duff-Gordon on the front page.

The court accepted the explanation as a charitable act towards the sailors. However, when the press, both American and British, learned of the empty lifeboat No. 1, the bribery charge and the £5, they crucified Cosmo Duff-Gordon. Lifeboat No. 1 went down in history as the millionaires’ boat.

Cosmo Duff-Gordon never regained his reputation for the rest of his life. His own wife left him in 1915.

The menu of the last dinner on the Titanic appeared in lifeboat No. 1

An original menu of the last first-class dinner held on the Titanic, with its 10 extravagant courses, turned up among the possessions of one of the passengers on lifeboat No. 1.

It was carried by Abraham Lincoln Salomon, the owner of a New York stationery store whom Officer Murdoch had allowed onto the lifeboat.

Titanic millionaire's boat
The menu that Abraham Lincoln Salomon had on him when he boarded lifeboat No. 1 boat. It lists the extravagant last first-class dinner, held a few hours before the Titanic sank. This piece of culinary history was sold at auction in 2015 for $88,000.

This menu is signed on the back by another first class passenger, Isaac Gerald Frauenthal, which suggests that they dined at the same table. Afterwards, Abraham continued the party in the first class lounge without retiring to his cabin, as he had the menu still in his hands when he boarded lifeboat No. 1.

Isaac Gerald Frauenthal had managed to board the second lifeboat that was launched, No. 5, along with his brother Henry Gerald Frauenthal and his brother’s wife Clara Rogers. The couple had just married in Nice the same year of the sinking, 1912. This was one of the newlywed couples allowed access to the lifeboats by Officer Murdoch.

Est.1875 

Nolumus credere, velimus scire

 Column II

Col2.com is free and independent media. We do not collect, store or sell personal data. This site sets no cookies and uses no Ggle Analytics or third party trackers. Ads may be served by external networks, which follow their own policies. If you see a Ggle consent pop‑up, it is because an ad slot on this site is filled by Ggle and Ggle requires user consent before displaying their ads. By using this website, the user agrees to the terms established in our privacy policy. These are our principles; should you not like them, we have others. Designed by Col2.com with WPress. We don’t want to believe, we want to know. Contact.