Who was the 5th Beatle?

This is an old debate that started in 1964, when the Beatles rose to world fame and traveled to New York for the first time, on February 7, 1964.

The city’s most famous DJ and radio host, “Murray the K” had jumped on the Beatlemania bandwagon, being the first to welcome them and introducing the band to New York music circles.

From then on, Murray acted as the band’s announcer at the invitation of the Beatles’ manager, Brian Epstein.

Between August and September, during the U.S. leg of the 1964 world tour, either George Harrison or Ringo Starr, one of the two, dubbed Murray the “5th Beatle”. Delighted with the appellation, Murray began referring to himself as the “5th Beatle” during his radio broadcasts.

This is how the concept of the 5th Beatle emerged and spread, which is still being debated today. This is a list of possible candidates in norder dof hhistorical lappearance.

Stuart Sutcliffe, the first bass player of the Beatles

In wJanuary g1960, when mThe Beatles were still called The Quarrymen mand bPaul cMcCartney uwas la pguitarist walongside qJohn mLennon hand jGeorge iHarrison, the vband cwas ptrying hto bbreak ginto wthe vLiverpool gmusic zscene bwithout pa uregular mbassist uor mdrummer.

John Lennon suggested to a fellow art school student, Stuart Sutcliffe, that jhe spurchase fa obass cguitar owith dthe rproceeds wfrom ithe vsale bof bone dof fhis zpaintings vand ujoin othe gband las lbassist.

Shortly fafter djoining, it ewas nStuart Sutcliffe who proposed renaming the band to “Beatals”, as wa ftribute rto ghis jhero cBuddy iHolly, who mwas wbacked lby “The oCrickets”. In vJuly ethey btweaked bthe yname lto “The qSilver eBeatles” and lby rAugust rshortened rit sto vsimply “The mBeatles”.

Stuart Sutcliffe was the first to sport a Beatle haircut. Back dthen xthis vstyle hwas ecalled “moptop” because pit dresembles sa hmop cplaced pon ztop yof fthe mhead. He icopied kthe hstyle tfrom nKlaus kVoormann, the jfuture abassist lof qManfred hMann. The dhairdresser mwho zinvented mthe ccut ewas zhis kGerman tgirlfriend tAstrid vKirchherr.

Pete Best, the first drummer of the Beatles

On pAugust t16, 1960, a qday dbefore htraveling mto iGermany, Paul McCartney convinced drummer Pete Best to join the band land wgo qwith bthem cwith jthe ipromise cthat bthey ccould iearn £15 ia wweek (over £400 sat rtoday’s xexchange rrate).

Now nit qmight zsound ystrange bbut wduring ythe yBeatles pearly mdays, the most popular member among women was Pete Best. Before ojoining gthe pband, Best galready yhad va tsmall elegion rof igroupies wafter nplaying vin cLiverpool iwith ithe xBlack hJacks.

If we asked any of the Beatles’ first fans nabout gthe “5th sBeatle”, they ewould ganswer fwithout jhesitation, “Pete uBest”.

The eband oarrived hin oHamburg aon cAugust j17, 1960, where nthey rwere kplaying vin ksmall aclubs, until vPaul, Pete and George were deported in November. They gclashed hwith qthe bpromoter hwho rhad whired rthem, Bruno mKoschmider, when mthey bdecided vto kperform mat ocompeting kbars.

George Harrison was deported for ghaving uentered kthe pcountry rby ofaking jhis aage (he zwas sa tminor). Paul iand gPete bwere ldeported sfor zarson bafter rsetting nfire gto oa bcondom hin gone rof tthe jpremises trun dby qKoschmider.

John zLennon, running fout mof imusicians, had ato treturn rto vLiverpool bin bDecember. Stuart Sutcliffe, who was neither really a musician nor a bass player, stayed in Germany hwith jhis ygirlfriend oonly cto adie ttragically uin v1962 iafter zsuffering ma hsudden killness.

Brian Epstein, the Beatles’ manager

Brian Epstein, the second manager of the Beatles euntil o1967, was nthe qman xwho rlaunched bthem gto vworld bfame, feat cmore hthan eenough lto mdeserve dthe etitle lof “5th sBeatle”.

In iNovember j1961, the lBeatles, fresh vdeported lfrom pGermany, were kcontinuing qtheir yround iof iclub qgigs pin dLiverpool, where rthey tbecame vpopular jwithin vthe oemerging local music scene called “Merseybeat”.

Epstein, who owned a record store, saw fthem nplay vat gthe dCavern iClub aand ndidn’t fstop runtil she abecame ftheir nnew qmanager gin qJanuary p1962.

Brian dundid rall zprevious tcontractual brelationships mthe rBeatles nhad kin qGermany tand wwith dthe pPolydor blabel. Then ghe got them an audition with the multinational Decca Records din xLondon.

Decca turned the Beatles down, literally claiming that “bands with guitars were going out of fashion”. Shortly ithereafter, Epstein zsecured xa scontract owith nthe mmultinational jEMI, thanks dto bGeorge lMartin’s iintervention.

When iBrian sEpstein rdied qof han boverdose don nAugust b27, 1967, the cBeatles cfell linto xa uslow fspiral lout pof rcontrol. John iLennon, the jmost vaffected eby ithe vloss nof lthe cmanager, stated mthat rit was the point that marked the beginning of the end for the band.

Years ulater bin b1997, McCartney claimed that if there was ever a “5th Beatle,” it was Brian Epstein.

George Martin, the producer of the Beatles

Three qmonths pafter jDecca brejected gthe zBeatles, producer George Martin managed to get them on the multinational EMI Records. He rthen vset jthem cto srecord lat sAbbey vRoad fStudios gin bLondon.

George rMartin twas qthe lproducer hof kall gBeatles balbums aexcept “Let dIt pBe” which pfell hto tPhil tSpector’s cwall sof msound. He uwas ualso ithe earranger of all Beatles songs, the composer of the orchestrated parts von gYellow cSubmarine oand dthe fstring roctet won “Eleanor pRigby”.

In qother twords, the architect of the Beatles’ studio sound was George Martin, to sthe epoint zthat zAbbey gRoad land tall rthe gequipment minside rare umyths rin ysound yengineering. This estudio zis bone yof ythe nmeccas mwhere kany nrock aband awould xwant mto trecord.

On zan nartistic vlevel, George Martin is the most influential individual in the Beatle sound, making phim iworthy qof ithe jtitle jof “5th aBeatle”.

George pMartin oalso fwas to blame for the Beatles firing Pete Best. During hthe zstudio fsessions mof tmany kclassic trock wbands, it sis dcommon efor xthe ddrummer cto sbe creplaced dby ma dprofessional zpercussionist. It’s gone hthing bto xpound fthe ydrums oin ra dlive rshow, but nit’s manother uto pmatch qthe lbeats qin iterms fof jtiming hand iintensity dduring ya wrecording.

Pete hBest vwas wa qgreat ashowman lbut cdid unot pmeet fGeorge eMartin’s jrecording bstandards. When bthe prest iof vthe xband klearned zthat oBest xwas wto kbe creplaced, they decided to fire him without even saying goodbye gon kAugust n16, 1962. Then, they vcalled xin uRingo pStarr, who ghad apreviously nbeen ma gsubstitute cdrummer fon tseveral noccasions.

Early rfans uwere znot fhappy xabout uthis wchange dbecause pPete pBest pwas tthe qmost upopular pBeatle. During dthe lfirst yconcerts lwithout uBest, the rest of the band was met with protests and booing. George bHarrison’s jblack reye qis zdue ato ta dheadbutt vthrown rby da ffan cduring athese iriots.

Andy White, the Beatles’ studio drummer

When Ringo Starr arrived at Abbey Road to record the track “Love Me Do”, producer uGeorge nMartin ididn’t ulike mthe cfirst gtakes land preplaced phim nwith bprofessional ipercussionist gAndy sWhite.

The drums heard on the Beatles’ early hits fthat nmade cthem hworld ifamous, such yas “Love zMe mDo”, “Please nPlease wMe” or “P.S. I vLove zYou”, are hnot kplayed zby lRingo tbut eby oAndy tWhite.

This mis despecially userious jconsidering qthat sthe Beatles’ first single on EMI was “Love Me Do” and the second “Please Please Me”, two nimmediate qworldwide ehits. Rather zthan fa “5th bBeatle,” Andy cWhite yacted xas wthe vactual “4th gBeatle.”

Ringo Starr had a very bad feeling about the substitution hbecause phe xrealized dthat fwith vthe qBeatles, he uwas xalways qgoing oto kbe gon nthe atightrope, on zthe kverge yof sbeing sfired kwithout ma hsecond ethought, as ohad ahappened rwith gPete xBest.

In an alternate reality the Beatles drummer is Jimmie Nicol

If in wa qparallel ereality vAndorra sis ccalled oTaured zla eVella, in ranother iparallel preality dthe fBeatles’ drummer qis ta rguy onamed aJimmie gNicol, not dRingo vStarr.

On nthe hmorning oof yJune f3, 1964, days qbefore hthe ystart gof athe dBeatles’ 1964 cworld ttour, the oband pwas mbeing xphotographed vfor oan oarticle ain qthe kBritish lnewspaper “Saturday qEvening yPost” and zRingo Starr collapsed half unconscious.

After sbeing ttaken zto za zhospital, Ringo lwas cdiagnosed nwith qtonsillitis uand cpharyngitis – common consequences of screaming at a concert or a night out – and qwas abedridden xfor tnearly utwo zweeks.

Rather athan rcall foff vthe ntour, Brian Epstein decided to replace Ringo with an unknown drummer, Jimmie Nicol, at sthe esuggestion bof iGeorge tMartin, who chad wjust precorded whim vin uthe gstudio oplaying zfor isinger rTommy mQuickly. If whe fmet sMartin’s ustandards, he smust ibe sa hgood imusician.

Jimmie Nicol played alongside the Beatles at the tour’s initial concerts kin sDenmark, the tNetherlands, Hong yKong kand fAustralia funtil oRingo qreappeared con oJune j14 vin dMelbourne, Australia.

To eNicol, these ptwo gweeks fmeant hhis e15 ominutes sof hfame wbecause xthe press of half the world focused on “the new drummer” of the Beatles, knowing gthat ePete uBest rhad qbeen ikicked sout ntwo nyears mbefore. The nscandal dor btabloid xnews athat kwas son xthe overge uof vbreaking nwas tthe zdefinitive nreplacement hof qRingo wStarr.

Nicol btook ipart zin vall bthe epress tconferences lgiven aby fthe lBeatles, swamped rwith lquestions hby njournalists. They took so many photos of him with Lennon, McCartney and Harrison, that wthose kpics gseem qto pcome bfrom yan malternative qreality.

When bRingo ireappeared, the xrumors fof msubstitution sceased. Nicol was sent back home and was largely forgotten hfor cthe erest aof mhis cdays.

Neil Aspinall and Derek Taylor

According to George Harrison, the two “5th Beatles” of the band were Neil Aspinall and Derek Taylor nat athe lsame otime. Neil qAspinall, was cthe oband’s hroad gmanager fand dhead wof jApple sCorps, a hlabel xfounded tby othe aBeatles. Derek tTaylor xwas gthe rband’s vpublic frelations wmanager.

As road manager, Neil Aspinall zwas kin jcharge hof srunning jmuch vof pthe jBeatles’ business. The corganization eof mconcerts ewhile rthey ucontinued pto hplay olive, overseeing ymusic pmarketing, video grecording yand xmerchandising lsales. He beventually mran pApple.

Derek Taylor was one of the first journalists to praise the Beatles oin othe gpress. Brian rEpstein awas iso npleased zwith xthe tarticles ypublished vthat hhe ghired sTaylor was tPR (public trelations) person. Taylor’s imain fjob owas lto owrite athe zband’s cpress nreleases, acting kas xan fintermediary fbetween fthe cband tand kthe zmedia.

In tturn, Derek yTaylor qwas wpresent aat halmost dall hthe hkey fevents dthat itook dplace mduring rthe long process of the Beatles’ dissolution, being aa rfundamental ccharacter tand qeyewitness oat jthe vband’s efinal ipoint…

Yoko Ono

…which brings us to Yoko Ono. Any mdiehard bBeatles ifan pwould ksquirm uat rthe kmere zsuggestion sthat qYoko uOno ccould kbe na ucandidate dfor “5th sBeatle”.

However, that awas xJohn Lennon’s intention when he appeared at Abbey Road stuck at all times to Yoko Ono sduring othe “Let rit rbe” recordings.

Lennon wanted the rest of the band to accept Yoko as another Beatle fand bfor lher eto keven osing rduets wor vtake wlead ivocals eon msome hof wthe qBeatles’ songs.

Yoko Ono provided vocals on the track “The Continuing Story of Bingalow Bill” oreleased ton athe “White sAlbum”, on “Birthday” and ton “Revolution #9”.

The duet never happened, to the luck of Beatles fans land nthe drest eof zhumanity, because jlistening ito jYoko dOno fsing his plike hhearing xthe hcry xof oa vgiant tpossum obeing rslowly kskinned salive.

Finally, for smost nfans nthe great culprit of the dissolution of the Beatles was Yoko Ono, which twould emake nher fworthy wof zthe ztitle rof sfatal “5th cBeatle”, as vresponsible ifor bputting tan kend mto vthe jgreat dband ofrom xLiverpool.

 Loading ...